Notes
subdivided hexagon iii solution

Solution to the Subdivided Hexagon III Puzzle

Subdivided Hexagon III

What’s the total area of this regular hexagon?

Solution by Properties of a Regular Hexagon, Similar Triangles, and Solutions of Quadratic Equations

Subdivided hexagon iii labelled

Label the points as in the diagram above, where II is such that GIG I is perpendicular to HFH F.

Let the side length of the hexagon be aa, then from the area of a regular hexagon, the total area of the hexagon is 332a 2\frac{3 \sqrt{3}}{2} a^2.

Let line segment BHB H have length bb. Then from the area of the purple triangle, ab=6a b = 6.

Let line segment GIG I have length hh. Using lengths in an equilateral triangle, IFI F has length 3h\sqrt{3} h. Triangles HBCH B C and HIGH I G are similar, so line segment HIH I has length ha×b=6ha 2\frac{h}{a} \times b = \frac{6 h}{a^2}.

The area of triangle HFGH F G is then 12h(6ha 2+3h)\frac{1}{2} h \left( \frac{6 h}{a^2} + \sqrt{3} h\right), so:

(1)h 2a 2(6+3a 2)=2 \frac{h^2}{a^2} \left( 6 + \sqrt{3} a^2 \right) = 2

Then, from the lengths in a regular hexagon, line segment BFB F has length 3a\sqrt{3} a, so:

6a+h(6a 2+3)=3a \frac{6}{a} + h \left(\frac{6}{a^2} + \sqrt{3} \right) = \sqrt{3} a

This rearranges to:

(2)h=3a6a6a 2+3=a(3a 26)6+3a 2 h = \frac{ \sqrt{3} a - \frac{6}{a} }{\frac{6}{a^2} + \sqrt{3}} = \frac{ a(\sqrt{3} a^2 - 6)}{6 + \sqrt{3} a^2}

Putting this into Equation (1) gives:

(3a 266+3a 2) 2(6+3a 2)=2 \left(\frac{\sqrt{3} a^2 - 6}{6 + \sqrt{3} a^2}\right)^2 \left( 6 + \sqrt{3} a^2 \right) = 2

which rearranges as follows:

(3a 26) 2 =2(6+3a 2) 3a 4123a 2+36 =12+23a 2 3a 4143a 2+24 =0 \begin{aligned} (\sqrt{3} a^2 - 6)^2 &= 2(6 + \sqrt{3} a^2 ) \\ 3 a^4 - 12 \sqrt{3} a^2 + 36 &= 12 + 2 \sqrt{3} a^2 \\ 3 a^4 - 14 \sqrt{3} a^2 + 24 &= 0 \\ \end{aligned}

Putting c=3a 2c = \sqrt{3} a^2 turns this into c 214c+24=0c^2 - 14 c + 24 = 0 which has solutions c=12c = 12 and c=2c = 2.

From Equation (2), if c=2c = 2 then h=12hh = -\frac{1}{2} h, which is negative, so this isn’t a solution to the original problem. Hence c=12c = 12 and so the area of the hexagon is 33a 22=3×122=18\frac{3 \sqrt{3} a^2}{2} = \frac{3 \times 12}{2} = 18.

Solution by Equations of Straight Lines, Area of a Triangle, and Properties of a Regular Hexagon

Subdivided hexagon iii rotated

The version of the diagram above is rotated so that AA is vertically above the centre, OO. Overlay a coordinate system so that OO is the origin, OAO A is along the vertical axis, and AA is at the point (0,2)(0,2) (note that this is likely to be a different scale than the one that gives the areas).

The point HH appears to also lie on the vertical axis. This is what will be demonstrated.

In this coordinate system, the line BFB F has equation y=1y = 1, so HH has yy-coordinate 11. Let its xx-coordinate be pp.

Point CC has coordinates (3,1)(-\sqrt{3},-1), so the line through CC and HH has equation:

y+1x+3=1+1p+3=2p+3 \frac{y + 1}{x + \sqrt{3}} = \frac{1 + 1}{p + \sqrt{3}} = \frac{2}{p + \sqrt{3}}

Point AA has coordinates (0,2)(0,2) and FF has coordinates (3,1)(\sqrt{3},1), so the line through AA and FF has equation:

y2x=123=13 \frac{y - 2}{x} = \frac{1 - 2}{\sqrt{3}} = - \frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}

This rearranges to x=3(2y)x = \sqrt{3}(2 - y).

Point GG is on the intersection of these lines. Let qq be its yy-coordinate, then this satisfies:

q+13(2q)+3=2p+3 \frac{q + 1}{ \sqrt{3}(2 - q) + \sqrt{3}} = \frac{2}{p + \sqrt{3}}

which rearranges to:

q=53p33+p q = \frac{5 \sqrt{3} - p}{3\sqrt{3} + p}

The areas of the purple and orange triangles are, in this coordinate system, given by 12×2×(p+3)\frac{1}{2} \times 2 \times (p + \sqrt{3}) and 12×(q1)×(3p)\frac{1}{2} \times (q - 1) \times (\sqrt{3} - p). Since the purple triangle is three times the area of the orange then:

p+3=32(q1)(3p)=3(3p)(3p)33+p p + \sqrt{3} = \frac{3}{2} (q- 1)(\sqrt{3} - p) = \frac{3( \sqrt{3} - p)(\sqrt{3} - p)}{3 \sqrt{3} + p}

This rearranges as follows:

(p+3)(33+p) =3(3p)(3p) p 2+43p+9 =963p+3p 2 0 =2p 2103p =2p(p53) \begin{aligned} (p + \sqrt{3})(3 \sqrt{3} + p) &= 3(\sqrt{3} - p)(\sqrt{3} - p) \\ p^2 + 4 \sqrt{3} p + 9 &= 9 - 6 \sqrt{3} p + 3 p^2 \\ 0 &= 2p^2 - 10 \sqrt{3} p \\ &= 2 p (p - 5 \sqrt{3}) \end{aligned}

So either p=0p = 0 or p=53p = 5 \sqrt{3}. The second of these is outside the hexagon, so we must have p=0p = 0.

This means that HH lies on the line OAO A, so then the purple triangle is one sixth of the area of the hexagon, meaning that the hexagon has area 6×3=186 \times 3 = 18.