Notes
three congruent rectangles solution

Solution to the Three Congruent Rectangles Puzzle

Three Congruent Rectangles

Three congruent rectangles overlap. How long is the diagonal?

Solution by Dissection and Congruent Triangles

Three congruent rectangles labelled

In the above diagram, GG, II, BB, and DD are where the the yellow rectangle meets the edges of the figure. Line segments LBL B and GKG K are horizontal, while ILI L and DKD K are vertical.

Triangles GMIG M I and GHIG H I are congruent, as are triangle BLIB L I and BAIB A I, triangles BNDB N D and BCDB C D, and triangles GKDG K D and GFDG F D. Therefore the sum of the areas of triangles GHIG H I, BLIB L I, BNDB N D, and GKDG K D is the same as that of triangles GMIG M I, BAIB A I, BCDB C D, and GFDG F D.

The latter comprises the region of the figure that is outside the yellow rectangle, but since the yellow rectangle is congruent to the blue and red, its area is half of the full diagram. Therefore triangles GHIG H I, BLIB L I, BNDB N D, and GKDG K D cover the same area as the yellow rectangle.

But those triangles cover the yellow rectangle with an overlap, namely the rectangle LMKNL M K N. Therefore, that rectangle must have zero area and so points BB and GG are at the same height.

The distance between BB and GG is therefore the same as the bottom side of the diagram, which is FF. This is also the diagonal of the yellow rectangle, so is also the length of line segment IDI D.

Solution by Similar Triangles and Pythagoras' Theorem

With the points labelled as above, let line segment HGH G have length aa, ACA C have length bb, and HIH I have length cc. Then IAI A has length 4c4 - c.

Triangles GHIG H I and IABI A B are similar since they are both right-angled and angles GI^HG \hat{I} H and AI^BA \hat{I} B add up to 90 90^\circ. Therefore:

ac=4cb \frac{a}{c} = \frac{4 - c}{b}

which rearranges to c(4c)=abc(4 - c) = a b.

Since the rectangles are congruent, GIG I has length 22 and IBI B has length a+ba + b. Therefore, applying Pythagoras' theorem to triangles GHIG H I and IABI A B produces:

a 2+c 2 =4 So c 2 =4a 2 (4c) 2+b 2 =(a+b) 2=a 2+2ab+b 2 So (4c) 2 =a 2+2ab \begin{aligned} a^2 + c^2 &= 4 \\ \text{So } c^2 &= 4 - a^2 \\ (4 - c)^2 + b^2 &= (a + b)^2 = a^2 + 2 a b + b^2 \\ \text{So } (4 - c)^2 &= a^2 + 2 a b \end{aligned}

Putting those together:

4 2 =(c+4c) 2=c 2+2c(4c)+(4c) 2 =4a 2+2ab+a 2+2ab 12 =4ab 3 =ab \begin{aligned} 4^2 &= (c + 4 - c)^2 = c^2 + 2 c(4 - c) + (4 - c)^2 \\ &= 4 - a^2 + 2 a b + a^2 + 2 a b \\ 12 & = 4 a b \\ 3 &= a b \end{aligned}

Therefore c(4c)=3c(4 - c) = 3 which rearranges to c 24c+3=0c^2 - 4 c + 3 = 0 and this has solutions c=1c = 1 and c=3c = 3. Note that 4c4 - c is the other solution, so without loss of generality take c=1c = 1.

Then a 2=4c 2=3a^2 = 4 - c^2 = 3, so a=3a = \sqrt{3} and likewise b=3b = \sqrt{3}. This means that a+b=23a + b = 2 \sqrt{3}, so the rectangles have side lengths 22 and 232 \sqrt{3}. Their diagonal is then 2 2+(23) 2=4+12=16=4\sqrt{2^2 + (2 \sqrt{3})^2} = \sqrt{4 + 12} = \sqrt{16} = 4.